- Why did the fish meat fall apart?
- You cooked it too long, or the soup boiled too hard. Fish meat structure is very loose, it cooks in minutes.
- What makes the broth 'jellied'?
- The collagen boiling out from the many fish bones and heads. If you only cook from fillets, it will never be as substantial.
Traditional Hungarian fisherman's soup
The soul of a good fisherman's soup is collagen. The gelatinous thickness of the stock cooked from fish bones and heads gives it that body which distinguishes fisherman's soup from a plain thin soup. The sweetness of paprika and onion counterbalances the distinct taste of the fish, creating one of Hungarian cuisine's most complex dishes.
Ingredients
600
g
Carp fillets (scored)
400
g
Catfish (fillet or steak)
2
heads
Onion
3
cloves
Garlic
3
tbsp
High-quality Paprika (sweet)
1
pc
Hot chilli pepper (to taste)
2
pcs
Tomato (or 1 tbsp puree)
2
tsp
Salt
0.5
tsp
Ground black pepper
1.5
litres
Fish stock (prepared in advance from bones and heads)
Shopping List (0)
Equipment Needed
- Large pot
- Sharp knife for filleting or slicing
Allergen Information
Fish
Instructions
1
✓
Chop the onion very finely, and sauté in a little fat or the fat skimmed from the top of the stock.
Tip: Chopping the onion is critical: it must boil away in the broth to thicken it.
2
✓
Remove from the heat, stir in the paprika, crushed garlic, and finely chopped tomato.
Tip: Paprika colour compounds dissolve really beautifully in fat.
3
✓
Pour on the hot fish stock, and boil together for 10-15 minutes until the onion softens completely.
Tip: Strong boiling helps emulsify the fat and water (the paprika and onion substances).
4
✓
Put the salted carp and catfish slices into the soup, along with the hot chilli (whole).
Tip: Salt the fish meat slightly in advance so its structure remains firmer during cooking (dehydration).
5
✓
Simmer gently for another 10-15 minutes. Do not stir, just shake the pot!
Tip: Stirring breaks the soft fish meat. Shaking is enough to prevent sticking.
6
✓
Remove the hot chilli before serving. Serve with fresh, soft bread.
Tip: Dipping bread is an essential part of the fisherman's soup experience.
Recipe FAQ
Ingredients
- 600 g Carp fillets (scored)
- 400 g Catfish (fillet or steak)
- 2 heads Onion
- 3 cloves Garlic
- 3 tbsp High-quality Paprika (sweet)
- 1 pc Hot chilli pepper (to taste)
- 2 pcs Tomato (or 1 tbsp puree)
- 2 tsp Salt
- 0.5 tsp Ground black pepper
- 1.5 litres Fish stock (prepared in advance from bones and heads)