- The soup turned cloudy.
- Either you let it boil vigorously (fat emulsified with water), or didn't skim the scum. Meat soup must only just move (simmer).
- It has no taste.
- There was too little meat/bone for the water, or you cooked it too briefly. Good meat soup needs time (min. 3-4 hours for beef).
Rich meat soup
Meat soup is not just food, it's medicine and the soul of Sunday lunch. The chemistry here is about extraction: the goal is to extract all flavour and nutrients from meat and vegetables into the water. The secret to clear, golden soup is patience and 'simmering' cooking.
Ingredients
1
kg
Beef (preferably bone-in: brisket, shin)
300
g
Carrots
200
g
Parsley root (or Parsnip)
1
pc
Kohlrabi (small)
0.5
bulb
Celeriac
1
head
Onion (skin on)
2
cloves
Garlic
1
bunch
Fresh celery leaves and parsley
200
g
Cauliflower (a few florets)
200
g
Potatoes
1
tbsp
Whole black peppercorns
1
tbsp
Salt
3
l
Cold water
Shopping List (0)
Equipment Needed
- Large pot (at least 5 litres)
- Sieve
- Ladle
Allergen Information
Celery
Instructions
1
✓
Put meat in pot, pour over cold water. Start heating on medium heat.
Tip: Always start cooking in cold water! This keeps pores open, flavours extract into liquid. If put in hot, you'd seal flavour in meat.
2
✓
When it boils, grey scum forms on top. Carefully skim this off with a sieve or spoon until soup surface is clear.
Tip: Scum is precipitated protein and impurities. If left in, soup becomes cloudy with off-flavours.
3
✓
Reduce heat to minimum (just simmering). Add salt, whole peppercorns, skin-on onion, and garlic. Cook meat alone for 1.5 hours.
Tip: Onion skin gives beautiful golden colour. Slow cooking is key to clear broth.
4
✓
Add cleaned vegetables (carrot, parsley root, celeriac, kohlrabi). Continue simmering.
Tip: Vegetables need less time than beef, hence added later.
5
✓
In last 20-30 minutes add potatoes, cauliflower, and herb bunches.
Tip: These soften fastest. Add herbs at end to retain aroma.
6
✓
When meat is tender, turn off. Rest 15 minutes, then carefully strain. Serve vegetables and meat separately.
Tip: During resting cloudy parts settle to bottom.
Recipe FAQ
Ingredients
- 1 kg Beef (preferably bone-in: brisket, shin)
- 300 g Carrots
- 200 g Parsley root (or Parsnip)
- 1 pc Kohlrabi (small)
- 0.5 bulb Celeriac
- 1 head Onion (skin on)
- 2 cloves Garlic
- 1 bunch Fresh celery leaves and parsley
- 200 g Cauliflower (a few florets)
- 200 g Potatoes
- 1 tbsp Whole black peppercorns
- 1 tbsp Salt
- 3 l Cold water